Reading In Praise of Athletic Beauty
Once again I’m teaching Writing the Sporting Body and once again the core text for the course is Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht’s In Praise of Athletic Beauty. I’ve made reference to this work in some other writing on here. But it’s a dense book, one that I consider in equal measures important and limited. And so I’d like to use the occasion of teaching it and this space to work through some thoughts and develop my understanding of it.
For today, I’d like to just work out a kind of overview of the text by summarizing what seem to be aims and giving you an outline of its structure. After that, I just plan to offer my readings, which is to say my understanding, interpretation, and questions concerning, the different sections of the book, in order, over the course of a number of posts.
The Book and Its Author
The book actually first appeared in a German-language edition under the title Lob des Sports in 20015. An English edition appeared in 2006, published by Harvard University Press. I haven’t seen the German and so I can’t speak to whether the English is a translation or substantially different book.
As for the author, Gumbrecht is a German-born (1948) Professor of Comparative Literature at Stanford University. In this capacity, he writes about national literatures in the Romance Languages and about European philosophy, especially French and German and especially of the 19th century. I’m not familiar with most of Gumbrecht’s work, but what I have encountered has been very impressive to me for its erudition, its breadth and scope, the quality of its writing, and the focused attention on the relationship between everyday experience and cultural artifacts and events. His book on sports seems primarily to grow out of his experience as sports fan, an experience that is informed by his familiarity with European philosophies of art and aesthetic experience.
What is the book about?
If you look at the book jacket, it will tell you that Gumbrecht’s book proposes “a powerful and provocative” argument that “the fascination with watching sports is probably the most popular and potent contemporary form of aesthetic experience.” Where we fans might simply call certain athletic moves or plays “beautiful,” Gumbrecht’s book is supposed to provide “the means to explore, understand, and enjoy even more acutely the untamed aesthetic experience that our words-in-passing barely suggest.” I’m not certain who wrote this prose. But my own experience with academic publishing leads me to guess that Gumbrecht himself at least provided its main lines.
(I haven’t decided yet, but it may also be important that the blurbs for the book come from Walt Harris [at the time Stanford’s football coach], Myles Brand [then President of the NCAA], and Diana Nyad [marathon swimmer and journalist].)
How is the book structured?
The book has four main parts, preceded by a short introduction. In outline form, it looks like this:
- Definitions (theoretical reflections on the key terms involved)
- Discontinuities (capsule histories of key periods in the history of Western sports, from classical antiquity to the present)
- Fascinations (descriptions, illuminated by examples, of some of what he believes we are drawn to in sports)
- Gratitude (a kind of existential meditation on some of the deeper life issues that the aesthetic experience of sports can lead us to encounter)
I’ve organized the first seven weeks of my course around sections 1, 2, 4, and 5 (omitting “Discontinuities” from the syllabus because we’ll be getting our history in other forms). But I’m interested in the book for reasons that go beyond this course. So here I’m planning to share my experience of reading through all twenty sections of text, section by section, in however polished or rough a form my notes, reflections and questions may appear. I hope it will be of some use to some readers and, as always, I welcome responses and dialogue.